Premature Death from Power Plant Pollution

New England Journal of Medicine published study:

Air pollution particles tied to death rate

By Janet McConnaughey

Associated Press


A study of the nation's 20 largest cities confirms that small amounts of air pollution particles less than one-fifth the width of a human hair are enough to raise the death rate. And the death rate climbs steadily along with the number of these fine particles. The study, conducted by researchers at the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, supports Environmental Protection Agency standards that were set in 1987 and revised in 1997, said Bob Perciasepe, EPA assistant administrator for air quality.

"The findings should squelch criticism that earlier research at the EPA, Harvard and elsewhere was inconclusive," said James H. Ware, dean of the Harvard School of Public Health. He said it shows that the fine particles, and not the weather, certain chemicals or other factors, drive increases in the daily death rate. The study, published in today's New England Journal of Medicine, looked at death rates and at the amount of "fine particulate pollution," that is, particles less than 10 microns across. A micron is one-thousandth of a millimeter.

Such particles come from just about everywhere: cars, power plants, construction, agriculture and road-related pollution, such as bits of brakes and tires. The study deals in amounts almost staggeringly small: micrograms, ten millionths of a gram, or about four ten-millionths of an ounce, per cubic meter of air.

Under EPA rules, the maximum allowable level of 10-micron particles in 24 hours is 150 micrograms per cubic meter. All 20 cities averaged levels of one third or less of the maximum. For each 10 micrograms of particles per cubic meter of air over a 24-hour period, the death rate from all causes rose just over one-half of a percentage point. To put it another way: If you take a large city where about 100 people die each day, and the fine particle pollution rises by 20 micrograms per cubic meter over 24 hours, you can add one death to the daily rate. Los Angeles averaged 148 deaths a day from 1987 through 1994, when the study took place. New York averaged 190.9, and Chicago 113.9. "Even though we are using this relatively crude measure, we are still finding an effect," said Dr. Jonathan M. Samet of Johns Hopkins.

New Study Finds 441 Deaths in Massachusetts Annually Due to Soot from Dirty Power Plants;
Power Plant Pollution Shortens Over 30,000 Lives Yearly Nationwide

Findings of the study released October 17, 2000 include:

In more polluted areas, fine particle pollution can shave several years off its victims' lives. Hundreds of thousands of Americans suffer from asthma attacks, cardiac problems and upper and lower respiratory problems associated with fine particles from power plants

The elderly, children, and those with respiratory disease are most severely impacted by fine particle pollution from power plants.

Metropolitan areas with large populations near coal-fired power plants feel their impacts most acutely - their attributable death rates are much higher than in areas with few or no coal-fired power plants.

Power plants outstrip all other polluters as the largest source of sulfates - the major component of fine particle pollution - in the U.S.

Approximately two-thirds (over 18,000) of the deaths due to fine particle pollution from power plants could be avoided by implementing policies that cut power plant sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide pollution 75 percent below 1997 emission levels.

To view the entire study, click